The work Theophanes Continuatus was a continuation of the chronicle of Theophanes the Confessor by other writers, active during the reign of her father. The chronicle ends in 961 and records her fate following the death of Constantine VII on 9 November 959. Her brother Romanos II succeeded to the throne and his wife Theophano convinced him to send all five of his sisters to the convent of Kanikleion.
Theodora and her sisters Zoe, Agatha, Theophano and Anna were initially held in Kanikleion. Later they were split with Theodora, Zoe and Theophano sent to the monastery of Antiochus while Agatha and Anna were sent to Myrelaion, a nunnery built by their maternal grandfather.
While the sisters were following their monastic lives, changes were occurring in the imperial throne. Romanos II died on 15 March 963. His co-rulers and successors were his underage sons Basil II and Constantine VIII. Theophano served as their Regent until marrying victorious general Nikephoros II. Nikephoros rose to the throne as senior Emperor. However Theophano and her lover John I Tzimiskes organized his assassination on the night of 10 December 969 – 11 December 969.
John became senior Emperor in place of his victim. Theophano was exiled to the island of Pringipos. However, unlike his predecessor, John lacked a connection to the legitimate Macedonian dynasty by either blood and marriage. His previous marriage to Maria Skeleraina had solidified an alliance with general Bardas Skleros. The loyalties of the rest of the Byzantine Empire were not as secure.
John rectified the situation by releasing Theodora from Myrelaion and arranging their marriage. According to Leo the Deacon the marriage occurred in November, 971. "The Cambridge Medieval History. Vol. IV, The Byzantine Empire" (1966) by Joan M. Hussey, attributes to this marriage the birth of a daughter:
Theophano Kourkouas. John I died on 10 January 976. Whether Theodora was still alive is not mentioned in Medieval sources.